Prince Street Pizza

Rick Lupert a month ago

I live for good pizza, and L.A. is experiencing a bit of a renaissance of spots like this that offer legit NYC-style slices and Sicilian square slices too. So naturally, when we learned of the existence of Prince Street Pizza, it was "added to the list." We tried a basic NY slice, a Green Machine NYC slice, a Sicilian Prince Street Perfection, and Sunset Square slices. They were all good with decent flavor. We think the dough was slightly undercooked on the Sicilian slices, but generally thought these were worthwhile slices to have, miles above chain or basic Italian restaurant pizza...but not our favorite from similar offerings at other newer local spots. If we lived nearby (We don't; we drove from Santa Clarita to check it out), it would definitely be a part of our regular rotation. The staff is awesome...really thoughtful and nice...got every detail of what we asked for right. Made a point of offering me my free cookie for signing up for the rewards program without me having to ask. Love the decor as well. You definitely get the local, small NYC slice vibe in the shop. It's definitely worth giving it a try!

M P 2 months ago

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Completely lived up to the hype! Phenomenal pizza & world-class service. My daughter has been so excited to try this place—she constantly watches YouTube clips of their pizza while eating back home. Since we don’t have a location up in the Bay Area, making a pitstop here during our SoCal trip was an absolute must. We visited on a Friday evening. It’s located in a cute, cozy shopping strip, and we were able to find parking without an issue. Inside, the space is clean, bright, and welcoming, with great decor like a fun Godfather poster on the brick wall. We ordered the Spicy Spring and some chocolate chip cookies. Because it was a busy Friday night, our order took a little under an hour to make it to our table. Honestly, we didn't mind the wait at all because the hospitality here is incredible. The wonderful man behind the counter found out it was our first time trying the place and brought us a variety of complimentary slices of their other pizzas to try while we waited. It completely made our night! Here is the breakdown of the food: The Pizza: Incredible across the board. The crusts were remarkably light, thick yet airy, and not heavy at all. The sauce flavor is absolut

Karina Marquina 3 months ago

First thing you notice when you walk in is the smell. It smells so good right away. There are so many options so I asked Amir for help. He said everything is great but recommended the Naughty Pie and said the Sunset is one of his favorites. Adriana jumped in and agreed, so I went with those. They did not disappoint. The Naughty Pie was tangy and sweet with the perfect crust, no soggy undercarriage at all. The Sunset was just as good. Sweet tomato sauce with a solid layer of cheese, simple but done right. The place feels nice and homey, staff is friendly, and the pizza is easily a 100/10. Definitely worth coming here again.

Stacking Voices Edited 4 months ago

Not your ordinary neighborhood slop. Gold standard quality in every bite. Im a huge fan of white cheese pizzas. Prince street pizza is one of very few spots that does white cheese pizzas that are good. Everything is done right. The pepperoni slice is the closest thing I've had to that fratellis slice at old yankees stadium. Glad to have prince street in the neighborhood.

Nicholas 10 months ago

The first thing I noticed wasn’t the smell of sausage or pepperoni. It was the fact that my pizza looked like it had been carved by someone philosophically opposed to straight lines. I ordered the Meat Lovers, double cut and well done. The bake was exactly what I asked for, so no issue there. The problem was the slicing. A proper double cut should give you neat, evenly sized pieces. Instead, I opened the box to a collection of irregular shapes that felt improvised on the spot. Angles that didn’t match. Chunks removed with no pattern. Some pieces so oddly formed they barely qualified as slices at all. The flavor was still good, the ingredients still solid, but the presentation turned the whole thing into a puzzle rather than a meal. Prince Street usually delivers consistency, which is why this stood out. Pizza this good deserves a bit more respect in the final step. I hope this was just an off night, because the quality of the slice is still there. It just needs someone with a steadier hand and a better sense of geometry.